Board Presidents Since 1871
| Augustus Schell | 1871 — 1884 |
| Charles B. Moore | 1884 — 1889 |
| John D. Jones | 1889 — 1895 |
| William H. H. Moore | 1895 — 1910 |
| Augustus N. Hand | 1910 — 1950 |
| John M. Harlan. II | 1950 — 1955 |
| William L. Savage | 1955 — 1974 |
| Eugene H. Nickerson | 1974 — 1978 |
| Thomas Thacher | 1978 — 1990 |
| Arthur V. Savage | 1990 — 2012 |
| Regina S. Peruggi | 2012 — Present |
Past Havens Managers
| Charles G. Havens | 1871 — 1888 |
| John D. Jones | 1871 — 1895 |
| Charles B. Moore | 1871 — 1893 |
| William M. Prichard | 1871 — 1897 |
| William Cutting | 1871 — 1897 |
| Clifford A. Hand | 1871 — 1901 |
| William H. H. Moore | 1871 — 1910 |
| Walter L. Cutting | 1871 — 1885 |
| Augustus Schell | 1871 — 1884 |
| Oliver S. Strong | 1871 — 1874 |
| John H. Gourlie | 1871 — 1891 |
| Alfred W. Craven | 1871 — 1879 |
| Benjamin F. Butler | 1871 — 1880 |
| Thomas C. Smith | 1871 — 1901 |
| William V. McDaniel | 1871 — 1884 |
| James A. Whitlock | 1871 — 1910 |
| John H. Pell | 1871 — 1902 |
| Isaac P. Smith | 1874 — 1914 |
| Howard W. Coates | 1879 — 1904 |
| James M. McLean | 1880 — 1890 |
| William E. Dodge, Jr. | 1884 — 1903 |
| Townsend Jones | 1884 — 1916 |
| Andrew Warner | 1886 — 1901 |
| Henry Parish | 1889 — 1916 |
| Grove P. Mitchell | 1890 — 1905 |
| William C. Sturges | 1891 — 1906 |
| Charles M. Bleecker | 1894 — 1946 |
| Samuel D. Davis | 1895 — 1912 |
| Cornelius Eldert | 1897 — 1913 |
| William Clifford Moore | 1897 — 1920 |
| Benjamin Strong, Jr. | 1901 — 1925 |
| Augustus N. Hand | 1901 — 1954 |
| Henry Dwight Chapin | 1901 — 1942 |
| Robert W. de Forest | 1903 — 1930 |
| Mornay Williams | 1904 — 1926 |
| Edmund Dwight | 1904 — 1933 |
| Charles Wisner | 1905 — 1927 |
| William M. Kingsley | 1910 — 1923 |
| Robert O. Hayward | 1912 — 1922 |
| Francis C. Huntington | 1913 — 1916 |
| Wilbur C. Fisk | 1914 — 1926 |
| Eliot Tuckerman | 1916 — 1956 |
| Guy Van Amringe | 1916 — 1931 |
| Henry Parish, Jr. | 1916 — 1942 |
| Edwin S. S. Sunderland | 1920 — 1964 |
| Percival Wilds | 1922 — 1943 |
| Catesby L. Jones | 1923 — 1944; 1946 — 1970 |
| Learned Hand | 1925 — 1953 |
| Frederick Toppin | 1926 — 1933 |
| Franklin B. Kirkbride | 1926 — 1931 |
| Edward S. Blagden | 1926 — 1966 |
| Thomas D. Thacher | 1927 — 1944 |
| Robert P. Patterson | 1930 — 1952 |
| Charles E. Hughes, Jr. | 1931 — 1950 |
| William L. Savage | 1931 — 1983 |
| Pierre Jay | 1935 — 1946 |
| John M. Harlan, II | 1936 — 1955 |
| Matthew G. Ely | 1936 — 1965 |
| Lindsay Bradford | 1943 — 1960 |
| Matthew Hale | 1943 — 1950 |
| R. McAllister Lloyd | 1943 — 1958 |
| Alfred C. Coxe, Jr. | 1944 — 1956 |
| William M. Evarts | 1944 — 1955 |
| Jesse Knight | 1949 — 1974 |
| Eugene H. Nickerson | 1950 — 2000 |
| John P. Morgan, II | 1951 — 1993 |
| Edward J. Dimock | 1953 — 1971 |
| Lewis B. Harder | 1953 — 1980 |
| Arthur V. Savage | 1954 — 2012 |
| Julian D. Fairchild | 1955 — 1990 |
| Daniel P. Davison | 1956 — 1970; 1974 — 1977 |
| J. Edward Lumbard | 1956 — 1960 |
| Thomas Thacher | 1956 — 1998 |
| Edward O. Miller | 1958 — 1990 |
| Bayard D. Clarkson | 1960 — 2025 |
| Leonard P. Moore | 1961 — 1981 |
| Decatur S. Higgins | 1965 — 1981 |
| Orson D. Munn, Jr. | 1965 — 1976 |
| William S. Ellis | 1966 — 2005 |
| Maurice D. Stack | 1970 — 1992 |
| Robert B. Whitney | 1970 — 1975 |
| Harold R. Tyler, Jr. | 1971 — 1981 |
| Constance Baker Motley | 1975 — 1977 |
| Carol H. Baldi | 1976 — 1998 |
| Charles S. Haight, Jr. | 1977 — 2008 |
| Paul J. Brignola | 1978 — 2015 |
| Frances Fabyan Davis | 1980 — 2002 |
| Michael Loening | 1981 — 2013 |
| Charles P. Sifton | 1981 — 2009 |
| Allan Comrie | 1981 — 1992 |
| Lawrence W. Pierce | 1983 — 1994 |
| JoAnn Delafield | 1990 — 2012 |
| George A. von Hassel | 1992 — 2014 |
| Cynthia C. Lefferts | 1993 — 2004 |
| Sarah L. Morgan | 1993 — 2011 |
| Robert P. Patterson, Jr. | 1995 — 2008 |
| David Plimpton | 1999 — 2019 |
| Jose A. Tavares | 2000 — 2019 |
| Russell G. D'Oench, III | 2002 — 2012 |
| Mildred García | 2006 — 2007 |
| Abigail Jones Feder | 2008 — 2014 |
| Deborah A. Batts | 2009 — 2020 |
| Stephanie Nickerson | 2010 — 2017 |
| Robert W. Sweet | 2010 — 2014 |
| Daniel P. Davison | 2011 — 2014 |
| Thomas D. Thacher, II | 2013 — 2017 |
| Frances G. Laserson | 2019 — 2021 |